Sublyna Logo

Skool vs Gumroad: Platform Comparison

For creators looking to monetize their digital products and communities, choosing the right platform can significantly impact your business growth. Skool and Gumroad offer different approaches to creator monetization, with distinct features tailored to specific use cases. This comparison breaks down their pricing models and key features to help you make an informed decision.

Skool logo

Skool

Skool is an all-in-one platform that combines community, courses, and events in a single interface with a flat monthly fee and low transaction fee.

Pricing Structure

Platform Fee: 2.9% - transaction fee

Payment Processing: 0% + $0 (domestic)Included in platform fee

Key Features

Community Discussion

Posts, comments, likes, mentions, real-time interactions

Course Platform

Integrated courses with progress tracking

Events Calendar

Scheduling with timezone conversion

Gamification

Points, levels, and rewards system

Unified Search

Search across posts, comments, courses, and members

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Lower transaction fee (2.9%)
  • Comprehensive community-building features
  • Integrated course platform with progress tracking
  • Built-in gamification and engagement tools
  • Auto-affiliate program (40% commission for referrals)

Cons

  • ×Fixed $99/month fee regardless of revenue
  • ×No free plan - higher upfront cost to start
  • ×Less focus on one-time digital product sales
  • ×No established marketplace for discovery

Example Calculation

For a creator with $1,000 in monthly revenue

Sale Price:$1000
Total Fees:$128
Your Earnings:$872

Best for creators focused on building interactive communities with courses, events, and gamification who prefer a unified platform approach.

Gumroad logo

Gumroad

Gumroad is a straightforward platform that helps creators sell digital products with simple transaction-based pricing and no monthly fees.

Pricing Structure

Platform Fee: 10% - standard fee

Payment Processing: 3.5% + $0.3 (domestic)per transaction

Marketplace Fee: 30% - for sales through Gumroad's Discover marketplace

Key Features

Digital Product Sales

Sell ebooks, courses, software, templates

No Monthly Fee

Pay only when you make a sale

Simple Setup

Quick and easy product listing

Basic Memberships

Limited subscription capabilities

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • No monthly fees - pay only when you sell
  • Simple, straightforward platform for beginners
  • Quick setup process for digital products
  • Established marketplace with wide recognition
  • Built-in email marketing features

Cons

  • ×Higher transaction fees (10% + $0.50 per transaction)
  • ×Limited community features
  • ×Basic course delivery capabilities
  • ×No gamification or events calendar

Example Calculation

For $1,000 in monthly sales on Gumroad

Sale Price:$1000
Total Fees:$135.8
Your Earnings:$864.2

Best for creators primarily selling digital products with one-time purchases who prefer simplicity and no monthly fees.

Overall Conclusion

Your choice between Skool and Gumroad should be based on your business model and monetization strategy:

- Choose Skool if you want to build an interactive community with integrated courses, events, and gamification features. Skool is ideal for creators who prioritize engagement, learning experiences, and are willing to pay a monthly fee for a comprehensive platform with lower transaction rates (2.9%).

- Choose Gumroad if you're primarily selling digital products (e-books, templates, software) with one-time purchases and prefer a straightforward platform with no monthly costs. Gumroad works best for creators who want simplicity and are just starting out, though it comes with higher transaction fees (10%).

For creators with higher monthly revenue, Skool's fixed monthly fee plus lower transaction rate might be more cost-effective in the long run. However, creators just starting out or with unpredictable sales might prefer Gumroad's pay-as-you-go model despite the higher percentage fees.